Hi, all.

I've a couple Rewrite rules for my site (an Insurrection/Subversion site)
and they work just fine when I add [R] for a redirect, except
I really would rather not do that.

And when I leave off the redirect, my verbose
rewrite log shows that the rule does get carried out,
but then passed through, and thus turned into a no-op.
What do I do to avert that?

Here's the rule:

RewriteCond %{REQUEST_METHOD} "^(GET|POST)$"
RewriteCond %{QUERY_STRING} "^$"
RewriteRule ^/nvs(/.*/)$ "/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=%{HTTPS}&Rewritten=ye s&Path=$1" [NE,L]

Works as specified when I add an R to the flags, but fails with this in the
logs when I neglect to:

66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) init rewrite engine with requested uri /nvs/faq/
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='Insurrection=(admin|atom|bandwidth|blame| diff|dump|get|log|ls|rss|savelog|uploaddir|upload) ' => not-matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*/)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='^r([0-9]+)$' => not-matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*/)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='^$' => matched
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) rewrite '/nvs/faq/' -> '/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path =/faq/'
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) split uri=/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path =/faq/ -> uri=/Insurrection/ls.cgi, args=Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path=/faq/
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) local path result: /Insurrection/ls.cgi
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) prefixed with document_root to /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi
66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (1) go-ahead with /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi [OK]
66.35.250.151 - omri [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (1) [perdir /var/www/html/Insurrection/] pass through /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi

Note the last two lines? What gives? Everything is fine, and
then there's a pass through.
--
Omri Schwarz --- ocschwar@mit.edu
Timeless wisdom of biomedical engineering: "Noise is principally
due to the presence of the patient." -- R.F. Farr

On 9 Feb, 06:17, Omri Schwarz <ocsc...@h-after-ocsc.mit.edu> wrote:
> Hi, all.
>
> I've a couple Rewrite rules for my site (an Insurrection/Subversion site)
> and they work just fine when I add [R] for a redirect, except
> I really would rather not do that.
>
> And when I leave off the redirect, my verbose
> rewrite log shows that the rule does get carried out,
> but then passed through, and thus turned into a no-op.
> What do I do to avert that?
>
> Here's the rule:
>
> RewriteCond %{REQUEST_METHOD} "^(GET|POST)$"
> RewriteCond %{QUERY_STRING} "^$"
> RewriteRule ^/nvs(/.*/)$ "/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=%{HTTPS}&Rewritten=ye s&Path=$1" [QSA,NE,L]
>
> Works as specified when I add an R to the flags, but fails with this in the
> logs when I neglect to:
>
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) init rewrite engine with requested uri /nvs/faq/
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='Insurrection=(admin|atom|bandwidth|blame| diff|dump|get|log|ls|rss|savelog|uploaddir|upload) ' => not-matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*/)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='^r([0-9]+)$' => not-matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) applying pattern '^/nvs(/.*/)$' to uri '/nvs/faq/'
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='GET' pattern='^(GET|POST)$' => matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (4) RewriteCond: input='' pattern='^$' => matched
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) rewrite '/nvs/faq/' -> '/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path =/faq/'
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (3) split uri=/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path =/faq/ -> uri=/Insurrection/ls.cgi, args=Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=on&Rewritten=yes&Path=/faq/
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) local path result: /Insurrection/ls.cgi
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (2) prefixed with document_root to /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi
> 66.35.250.151 - - [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (1) go-ahead with /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi [OK]
> 66.35.250.151 - omri [09/Feb/2007:00:53:22 --0500] [server.mit.edu/sid#88fcdb8][rid#a34ff78/initial] (1) [perdir /var/www/html/Insurrection/] pass through /var/www/html/Insurrection/ls.cgi
>
> Note the last two lines? What gives? Everything is fine, and
> then there's a pass through.
> --
> Omri Schwarz --- ocsch...@mit.edu
> Timeless wisdom of biomedical engineering: "Noise is principally
> due to the presence of the patient." -- R.F. Farr

Query String Append?
[QSA,NE,L]

"shimmyshack" <matt.farey@gmail.com> writes:

> On 9 Feb, 06:17, Omri Schwarz <ocsc...@h-after-ocsc.mit.edu> wrote:
> > Hi, all.
> >
> > I've a couple Rewrite rules for my site (an Insurrection/Subversion site)
> > and they work just fine when I add [R] for a redirect, except
> > I really would rather not do that.
> >
> > And when I leave off the redirect, my verbose
> > rewrite log shows that the rule does get carried out,
> > but then passed through, and thus turned into a no-op.
> > What do I do to avert that?
> >
> > Here's the rule:
> >
> > RewriteCond %{REQUEST_METHOD} "^(GET|POST)$"
> > RewriteCond %{QUERY_STRING} "^$"
> > RewriteRule ^/nvs(/.*/)$ "/Insurrection/ls.cgi?Insurrection=ls&HTTPS=%{HTTPS}&Rewritten=ye s&Path=$1" [QSA,NE,L]
> >
[...]
>
> Query String Append?
> [QSA,NE,L]
>

Close. PT wound up doing the trick.

Thanks, though!

--
Omri Schwarz --- ocschwar@mit.edu
Timeless wisdom of biomedical engineering: "Noise is principally
due to the presence of the patient." -- R.F. Farr